Showing up to fourth grade picture day after a botched haircut and hearing, “What happened to your head?” from a classmate haunts me to this day, and likely will forever. Even so, that experience pales in comparison to that of a man with no social experience and scissors for hands, thrust into a too small town of gossiping housewives and their unconcerned husbands. Such is the fate of Edward Scissorhands.
Created in a lab, with his progenitor now deceased, Edward spends countless months alone in a gothic castle which looms over the nameless suburb. As with many aspects of the film’s presentation, the contrast is stark and definite but not heavy handed. Completely unaware of the world outside of the castle and its beautiful gardens, tended to by Edward’s own blades, a hapless door-to-door saleswoman, Peg Boggs, stumbles in and brings him into town.
The things which typify a suburban environment, such as pastel homes with near identical floor plans and freshly trimmed lawns, are so utterly homogenous that they only serve to unsettle. The set design and cast of intrusive neighbors highlight societal norms which are often taken for granted, and become oppressive in their conformity.
Edward is clearly an outsider, and the nosy townsfolk take note before he can get settled. Beyond the obvious, his face is pocked with scars from self-inflicted wounds. In his first attempt to dress in civilian clothes, he tears them to shreds and slices clean through a pair of suspenders. Edward is effectively an infant when it comes to etiquette and social matters, rarely speaking and often misunderstanding what is said to him. He doesn’t even respond when referred to as Ed, likely because he fails to recognize it as a shortened version of his own name.
In a town where your business is everyone’s business, Edward’s quirks quickly turn him into a novelty item. He is constantly paraded around town, encouraged to give eccentric haircuts and coerced into handling the neighborhood’s gardening duties. That is until the differences become too stark and the sheen begins to come off. Outliers are only used as showpieces, not to be truly accepted into society.
The film doesn’t stop its critique at a community level, but brings it to a personal, familial level. Seated around the Boggs’ family’s dinner table, Mr. Boggs poses an ethical question to Edward, concerning what he should do if he stumbled upon an unmarked briefcase full of money. With childlike charm, Edward claims he would like to give it to his friends, but Mr. Boggs, is quick to remark that the proper thing to do is to take it straight to the authorities. Kim, the family’s daughter and Edward’s crush, speaks up for Edward. It is one of the many instances in which we see the personal good compared to the common good, and individual desires set against public expectations.
There are further questions prompted concerning spirituality, as well as the contrast between the organic and the artificial. Edward is a manmade construct, and despite his stunted social nature, he possesses all interior aspects of a human. He clearly feels love, sorrow, and shame, yet the religious zealot in town curses him and calls for a return from whence he came. It is difficult, if not impossible, to say what defines a human, but it is a question which the film doesn’t hesitate to bring up.
Despite its weighty nature, the film does not take itself too seriously and is full of enchanting moments. In a tender encounter between Edward and Kim, she tells him, “Hold me,” to which he replies, “I can’t.” It is a dismal scene which highlights Edward’s own defects, but in a self-aware, lighthearted manner. It is moments such as these, in which abnormality and empathy are married, that the film works best – and there are plenty.
As always, Tim Burton beautifully places the mad, strange, and misunderstood at the forefront of the story, doing so in his signature style, which despite its bright colors and eccentric costumes retains a peculiar authenticity. Edward Scissorhands is far from your traditional heartwarming Christmas story, but it is an endearing tale which will resonate with the insecurities in all of us.